fbpx
Research
June 4, 2018

BMS Battlegrounds: Practical Advice for Litigating Personal Jurisdiction After Bristol-Myers

Bristol-Myers Squibb Co. v. Superior Court signifies the culmination of the Supreme Court’s paradigm shift in personal jurisdiction jurisprudence. It marks the Court’s clearest statement yet that jurisdictional forum shopping and verdict chasing are disfavored, and that courts should carefully evaluate personal jurisdiction challenges to ensure fairness and predictability for defendants.

Notwithstanding the Supreme Court’s decree, plaintiffs’ counsel continue to try and chip away at BMS, given its potential impact on their previously tried-and-true strategies. And although most courts have recognized the paradigm shift, some courts, particularly at the trial level, have not. Defendants must accordingly remain diligent in litigating personal jurisdiction issues in lower courts, particularly those courts historically skeptical of such arguments, to ensure that the Supreme Court’s directives in Bristol-Myers are implemented nationwide. Among other actions, the paper encourages defendants to:

  • Urge judges to demand a connection between a defendant’s actions and the forum in question;
  • Support the equal application of BMS to mass torts and national class actions;
  • Resist “fishing expedition” requests for jurisdictional discovery; and
  • Move quickly to challenge improper venue claims in ongoing cases that pre-date BMS.
View PDF
Torts of the Future: Drones Mass Tort Multidistrict Litigation Fall 2021 | ILR Research Review | Volume 8, Issue 2 Class Action Litigation, Data Privacy, Mass Tort Multidistrict Litigation, Municipality Litigation, Third Party Litigation Funding (TPLF) ILR Briefly: Twisted Blackjack: How MDLs Distort and Extort Mass Tort Multidistrict Litigation Fact or Fiction: Ensuring the Integrity of Expert Testimony Class Action Litigation, Mass Tort Multidistrict Litigation Trials and Tribulations: Contending with Bellwether and Multi-Plaintiff Trials in MDL Proceedings Mass Tort Multidistrict Litigation

Cookie Notice

By clicking “I Accept”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts.

Cookie Notice

By clicking “I Accept”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Review Settings