fbpx
News
August 27, 2019

An Oklahoma Opioid Stickup

“An Oklahoma Opioid Stickup”: The Wall Street Journal editorial board took aim at yesterday’s ruling by an Oklahoma judge that Johnson & Johnson must pay $572 million for what Judge Balkman called “misleading marketing” of opioids in the state, even though the company’s sales make up less than one percent of Oklahoma’s prescription opioid market. Little of that money will go directly to plaintiffs, but their lawyers will take home $90 million.

As the editorial board points out, the ruling relied on a distorted application of public nuisance law, which does not require a direct causal link between a defendant’s action and harm to a plaintiff. With this bench verdict, Judge Balkman has added fuel to many of the over 2,000 cases in the federal opioid litigation in Ohio which rely on public nuisance. He has also effectively confirmed that public nuisance laws can be used to skirt the more stringent requirements of product liability law, validating recent efforts by the trial bar and state AGs to use this legal theory as a basis for suing energy companies over climate change. As ILR President Lisa Rickard said in response to the ruling, under public nuisance “almost any industry could be the target of large-scale litigation.”

Summit 2022 Cropped Graphic Podcasts The Critical Role of State Attorneys General State Attorneys General Blog WSJ Editorial: "The Oklahoma Supreme Court Shreds Abuse of the ‘Public Nuisance’ Tort” State Attorneys General News Freedom Foundation: Court Loss For Minnesota AG Is A Win For Accountability, Transparency State Attorneys General News New Research: Litigation vs. Restoration: Addressing Louisiana’s Coastal Land Loss Municipality Litigation, State Attorneys General Wooden Gavel Blog Texas Lawmakers Should Keep Trial Lawyers Out of Taxpayers’ Pockets State Attorneys General

Cookie Notice

By clicking “I Accept”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts.

Cookie Notice

By clicking “I Accept”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Review Settings